5 Ways Pastors Wish They Did Differently After Revitalizing Their Church

Church revitalization is a challenging but rewarding process. Many pastors who have successfully led their congregations through seasons of renewal and growth often reflect on their experiences with pride and humility. While celebrating their achievements, they also recognize areas where they could have approached things differently. 

1. Cultivated More Patience in the Process

One of the most common reflections from pastors who have led church revitalization efforts is the wish that they had exercised more patience throughout the process. Revitalizing a church is rarely a quick fix, and many leaders are frustrated by the pace of change.

The renowned 19th-century preacher Charles Spurgeon once said, "By perseverance, the snail reached the ark." This quote encapsulates the importance of steadfast patience in ministry, especially during transition and growth.

Dr. Thom Rainer, a leading expert in church growth for many decades, emphasizes the need for patience in his research. In a study of successful church turnarounds, Rainer found that significant, lasting change often took 3-7 years to manifest fully.

Pastors who have been through the revitalization process often wish they had communicated this reality more clearly to their congregations. Setting realistic expectations about the timeline for change can help reduce frustration and burnout among leaders and church members.

To cultivate more patience, pastors can:

- Regularly remind themselves and their teams of the long-term nature of revitalization

- Celebrate small victories along the way

- Focus on incremental progress rather than a dramatic, overnight change

 2. Invested More in Leadership Development

Another common reflection from pastors is the wish that they had invested more heavily in developing leaders within their congregation earlier in the revitalization process. Many found that their efforts could have been improved by a lack of capable, aligned leaders to help carry the vision forward.

The apostle Paul's approach to ministry, as outlined in 2 Timothy 2:2, provides a biblical model for this principle: "And the things you have heard me say in the presence of many witnesses entrust to reliable people who will also be qualified to teach others."

 In my discoveries throughout New England, churches experiencing revitalization were significantly more likely to have robust leadership development programs in place.

Pastors who have successfully led church turnarounds often advise:

- Identifying potential leaders early in the process

- Providing regular, intentional mentoring and training opportunities

- Delegating responsibilities to develop leadership skills in practice

3. Focused More on Spiritual Renewal Than Programmatic Changes

While programmatic changes are often necessary during church revitalization, many pastors wish they had emphasized spiritual renewal more from the outset. They found that lasting change was more effectively driven by a deepening of faith and spiritual vitality among the congregation.

The prophet Zechariah reminds us of the spiritual nature of true renewal: "Not by might, nor by power, but by my Spirit, says the Lord of hosts" (Zechariah 4:6, ESV).

 Dr. Ed Stetzer, a prominent researcher in church growth and revitalization, has consistently found that spiritual vitality is a key indicator of church health and growth potential. In his known studies, churches experiencing renewal always demonstrated a renewed focus on prayer, Bible study, and personal discipleship.

Pastors looking to prioritize spiritual renewal might consider the following:

- Implementing church-wide prayer initiatives

- Focusing sermons and small group studies on core spiritual disciplines

- Encouraging and equipping members for personal evangelism and discipleship

 4. Communicated Vision More Consistently and Creatively

Many pastors who have led church revitalization efforts wish they had communicated their vision more consistently and creatively throughout the process. They found that even when they thought they were over-communicating, many in the congregation still needed clarification about the direction and goals of the revitalization efforts.

The Old Testament prophet Habakkuk understood the importance of clear vision-casting: "Write the vision; make it plain on tablets, so he may run who reads it" (Habakkuk 2:2, ESV).

Research in organizational change management consistently shows that effective communication is critical for successful transformations. With any organization, having a clear, well-communicated vision was more likely to experience growth and revitalization.

To improve vision communication, pastors can:

- Use multiple channels to share the vision (sermons, emails, social media, small groups, etc.)

- Regularly tie current activities and decisions back to the overarching vision

- Use storytelling and testimonies to illustrate the vision in action

5. Prioritized Self-Care and Personal Spiritual Growth

 Finally, many pastors who have led church revitalization efforts wish they had prioritized self-care and spiritual growth more intentionally throughout the process. The demands of leading significant change can be exhausting, and many find themselves approaching burnout at various points.

 Jesus modeled the importance of self-care and spiritual renewal, often withdrawing to quiet places to pray and rest (Luke 5:16).

A study published in the Journal of Psychology and Christianity found a strong correlation between a pastor's spiritual practices and their effectiveness in leading church growth and revitalization.

To prioritize self-care and spiritual growth, pastors can:

- Establish regular rhythms of rest and renewal, including a weekly Sabbath

- Engage in ongoing personal study and spiritual direction

- Cultivate relationships with mentors and peers outside their congregation 

Reflecting on these five areas – cultivating patience, investing in leadership development, focusing on spiritual renewal, communicating vision effectively, and prioritizing self-care – can help pastors currently engaged in or considering church revitalization efforts. By learning from the experiences of those who have gone before, leaders can approach the challenging but rewarding work of church renewal with greater wisdom and effectiveness.

 It's important to remember that every church's revitalization journey is unique. What works in one context may not be directly applicable in another. However, these principles, grounded in biblical wisdom and supported by research, provide a solid foundation for approaching church revitalization with both courage and humility.

As you consider your own church's needs and opportunities for renewal, take heart in the words of the apostle Paul: "And I am sure of this, that he who began a good work in you will bring it to completion at the day of Jesus Christ" (Philippians 1:6, ESV). God is ultimately the one who brings about renewal and growth in His church. Our role as leaders is to faithfully steward the resources and opportunities He provides, always relying on His grace and guidance.

Photo: